Posts tagged tithing
Bible in a Year – Day 28: What’s a Life Worth?
Jan 28th
Today’s Reading: Exodus 30, 31 & 32
As with just about every day, there’s a lot packed into today’s reading. However, there were two parts that really jumped out to me and they both follow a similar theme. First, there is the “atonement money” that God requires every person to pay. Second, there is this conversation between Moses and the Lord where Moses asks God to forgive the Israelites for worshiping the golden calf. Both, I think, demonstrate a fundamental truth about the value of each individual – a truth that God first taught Noah and then, Noah articulated back to God.
Let’s take a look at the atonement money. The purpose of this money was to offer a “ransom” for the life of each individual. Clearly, this has some prophetic undertones as Jesus would pay the ultimate ransom for us and would be the ultimate atonement. However, I think there’s something interesting about this passage. God requires that everyone is to give one half shekel. And he specifically says that the rich are to give no more than a half shekel and the poor are to give no less.
Now, whenever God and money are combined in the Bible, most people immediately believe that the passage must be a commentary on church giving, tithing, etc. In this case, though, I don’t think that’s the point at all. In fact, when you read through the rest of scripture, you see that God typically does require more from those who have more and often lessens the giving requirements for those who are poor. So what’s going on here?
Well, remember that we’re talking about a ransom or atonement. That is, a sum of money paid in exchange for someone’s life. What’s a life worth? Whatever the person who saves your life says it’s worth. In this case, God tells the people that they are to pay one half shekel as a ransom for each life. But what is God going to do with a half shekel? He doesn’t need the money! What he does need is that for the people to understand that their lives have value and that no one person’s life is more valuable than another. The lives of the rich aren’t worth more than the lives of the poor or vice versa. This is a lesson in the value of a life, not a story about tithing or church giving.
This same lesson, then, is obviously learned and articulated by Moses when he says to God in chapter 32, verses 31 & 32:
“Oh, what a great sin these people have committed! They have made themselves gods of gold. But now, please forgive their sin—but if not, then blot me out of the book you have written.”
Moses here is essentially telling God that his life (or more accurately, his soul or his existence) is not any more valuable than anyone else’s. If they aren’t going to be forgiven – if they’re going to be rejected by God – then Moses doesn’t want to be accepted by him either. It’s a reminder that we’re all in this boat together – that God interacts with humanity as a whole as well as individuals. And it’s a reminder that you are worth the same as me and the same as the poorest of the poor and the richest of the rich. And, ultimately, Jesus would pay the same price for all of us.
Tithing, Generosity and Me
Mar 22nd
Todd Hunter has tithed for 32 years and says it never really impacted his life. In this interview from RecycleYourFaith.com, Todd kind of calls himself out for it. I think it has far reaching implications for how we think about giving in the church.
Tithing Without Generosity from Recycle Your Faith on Vimeo.
I like the honesty from Todd on this subject and I like that he is “thinking it through.” I believe there is a danger, however, in looking at things like tithing or worship or generosity and saying, “How has this impacted my life?” In other words, “What did I get out of this thing?” We begin to dig ourselves into a deep hole when we start to look at our relationship with God as a transaction – I give God 10% and he gives me ________ or I volunteer X amount of hours at church every week and God gives me ________. I agree with Todd’s conclusion that there is a fundamental generosity that is being taught in scripture and I don’t believe that Todd is viewing his tithe as some sort of transaction with God. I just think there is danger that a phrase like “How has this impacted my life?” could lead some people down the wrong rabbit trail.
In fact, I think a better question to ask is, “How has my giving impacted others?” If you can’t answer that question, then perhaps you need to dig a little deeper. I look at my church giving over the years and I can see how it has impacted other people – through ministry to people from many walks of life, through outreach to the community and help for people in need, through the building of a community that helps to carry the heavy load of tragedy and that celebrates together in times of joy. Outside of giving to the church, I’ve seen how others benefit from other forms of giving (whether monetary or otherwise) and how a small thing can make a huge impact on a person’s life.
Ultimately though, Todd and I agree. We should be giving generously, gladly and eagerly. We should give in anticipation of the good that will come from that gift. And, I’ll add, we should give to God knowing that he first gave to us and that he has a better plan for our money than we do. That’s a lesson I’ve learned over and over and continue to learn.
Each man should give what he has decided in his heart to give, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver.
2 Corinthians 9:7
